The biggest, er, "music" event the world has ever seen is over. I haven't clocked the US portion yet and get the feeling it may have stunk but you can't help wondering what the hordes out there reckoned to The Kaiser Chiefs '77 propelled pop. But anyway here - the 'big acts' that opened because they had to hightail it to destinations elsewhere for proper shows were all pretty much cruising. Macca's performance of Sargeant Pepper with U2 was every bit as lame as expected. It made ME, of all people, think that even O*sis could have made a better fist of it. A consideration that has disturbed me since I thunk it. And so it went, Coldplay made me pine for Dire Straits and fetching Richard Ashcroft from the freezer didn't help. And what was with Elton John dragging Pete (I'll Never Be Shane McGowan) Doherty out to kick "Children Of The Revolution" around the park. Product placement like this was something that the show didn't need. It all trundled along with Ricky Gervais' dance being decidedly more rock'n'roll than much of what preceded it. REM were an exception to this rule, they performed a perfect three song set and made me wish I'd caught them in Glasgow just a couple of weeks ago.
The serious aspect of the reason for all this remains to be vindicated. Maybe these G8 leaders will have to take notice but do you trust any of them? Obviously if you could go and help the people that they make these "films" between the bands about you would. If you could go direct to them but there's something lairy (to quote The KC's) about the process. But anyway, it's those intentions and that road to the burny fire again. Nobody can question or sully Geldof's intentions but the event itself is hijacked by it's apparent scale. The wheeling on and off by industry-sanctioned success stories at various degrees on the ladder of perceived popularity all becomes a tad too much. Nobody is more cynical or more jaded than I am but there was the odd flicker of humanity that suggested, despite and in consideration of all odds, this campaign might bear fruit.
It was a long haul. The Pistols reunion never happened and nobody was there to represent that era of Punk. Green Day were in Berlin and it made me consider that maybe, if they were still around, somebody would have had the good sense to involve The Ramones. 29 years ago tomorrow, my buddies and I were larking about in Hyde Park just prior to their Roundhouse debut but there I go digressing again.
A short burst of The Red Elvises from Moscow would have been welcome but wasn't to be. By the time Robbie Williams came on, the game show host turned entertainer or is it the other way about, rolled out his cheeky chappie schtick and the crowd went berserk. This is the problem right here and his crowd are the mobile phone toting, attention deficient solution. No point in mithering about it.
Peter Kay came on and did what the former Take That donkey did single handed. The crowd buoyed by their RW fix went bonkers and did a 200,000+ impromptu redition of Amarillo. Kay is a genius and if the world was in his hands then the story might be different. I wonder if he was beamed to the US? If he was, I wonder what the US unconciousness thought was going on. Something entirely alien to their culture I expect. The came The Who. They were fantastic. Did the CSI Theme and "Won't Get Fooled Again" and left. The energy of their performance lit the whole planet up.
And Pink Floyd. Bloody hell. I saw them on the "Wish You Were Here" tour and was singularly unimpressed but there was an almost folky quality to their ambience which really worked. When Roger Waters dedicated "WYWH" to Syd, the emotional undertow to this short burst out of retirement was palpable. Maybe they'll save the world from Radiohead after all. I'm no fan but they were good by any stretch of the imagination and credit was most definitley due. And similarly McCartney, my Beatlephobia is legend but his band pulled him through. Where his trawl through his back catalogue at Glastonbury last year was embarassing, these guys were tight an proficient an made him look good. Not an easy task in these eyes and ears I can tell ya.
And that was it, possibly not the outright train wreck one might have expected. And, if it does raise awareness of what it was arranged to do then that's grand. However, if the sensory gratification of the event does little more than increase sales for the people who "gave their services" then that would, to put it mildly, suck. Let's see how the land lies a week from now...
Late extra - Just finished fast forwarding through the Philadelhia segment and it was beyond excrecable. I'm tempted to say lamer than US foreign policy but that would be damning it with faint praise. Maroon 5 tickling "Rockin' In The Free World" to death. Stinkin' Park plus Jay Z futzing though some rock/rap fiasco, had they been granted the chance, The Star Spangles could have taken the whole bill with one hand between them. When will their "Gangland" save the world? No wonder the music biz is headed down the dumper. As for the "urban" quotient, this stuff patently doesn't work live. To me, much of it doesn't fly at all but these gimps can't even mime.
I'm now in recovery, using a mix of Mose Allison's "My Backyard" and The Groovers "Undergroove" to ease the trauma of what I witnessed in the pursuit of my, um, "art". Serves me bloody well right you're probably thinking and I cannae disagree. Still if this cosy, cosetted world of make believe can act as a stepping stone to ridding the planet of the poverty blight then so be it. I can't help thinking that it'd be a tad more swallowable if there was some substance behind it but I'm a contrary SOB at the best of time.
5 comments:
I dont like your write up of this event,this blog is getting boring, I have been quite addicted to it, but I think I will stop coming now.
You should stick to what you know, its more fun that way
Frankly, I think Lindsay knows pretty much about what he's writing about (lameoid rocksters who get together for such worthy causes in order to massage their feelings and let us all know just what wonderful sports they are giving their personal time and energy in order to make the world better for all of us). If anything, Lindsay was kinda restrained in his "Live 8" commentary but I guess that's the way he does things. All I must say is keep up the good work!
It's your perogative, like the TV on/off button or the channel/track/whatever changer on your remote. Where's the fun in sticking with what you know?
Yeah I was kinda restrained, attempting to be objective but trying to lay an angle on all of this that was maybe outside the general flood of reporting. It would have been too/very easy to wade in and take the piss out out of it all.
Keep up the good work Lindsay. You "know" Live 8 way more than most of those mainstream music scribes who string out the gushing, acritical comments. I just wonder how you could watch as much of it as you did. U2 & McCartney collaborating on "Sgt Pepper's" w/ those guys dressed like fake psychedelic Beatles playing fake French horns certainly marked this year's "Death of Music?" as opposed to death of hunger or whatever the focus of this dreadful event was supposed to be.
I watch these things because it allows me to use the experience to try and forge some kinda truth and perspective with regard to what should be in the rock firmament. I couldn't bring myself to even admit Velvet Revolver even existed fer instance but they do and apparently the "kids" love them. Even the Charles Hawtrey-esque lead singer. No disrespect to the real CH intended. Many of these acts will continue their campaigns of hoovering up money at the slew of festivals which take place between now and September. People will throw a Coldplay cd in with their weekly shop in Tesco. That's where the real damage is done. As for matey who took the strop well...
Post a Comment